★ .22LR Knowledge Base
Wind Drift vs Muzzle Velocity
at Low Muzzle Velocities
By Gary Riecke
Common sense would tell us that a bullet with a higher muzzle velocity would get to the target faster than a slower bullet and therefore have less wind drift. However, at lower muzzle velocities such as those of black powder era cartridges and the .22 Long Rifle rimfire, wind drift charts and ballistics solvers show an increase in muzzle velocity results in an increase in wind drift.
I’ve been wanting to conduct a field test to see if, at lower muzzle velocities, an increase in muzzle velocity does result in an increase of wind drift as the science says it will.
Under normal shooting conditions where changes in muzzle velocity are not large, the predicted increase in wind drift due to an increase in muzzle velocity would be hard to observe — especially if it is not something we are looking for. For example, at standard atmospheric conditions a .22 Long Rifle cartridge with a muzzle velocity of 1050 fps and a ballistics coefficient of .150 in a 5 mph wind from the left or right will have a wind drift of 1.89 inches at 100 yards. If the muzzle velocity is increased by 50 fps to 1100 fps, the wind drift is 2.05 inches — an increase of only .16 inches. Not enough to notice if the group size is average for that distance and cartridge.
Because of this I wanted to do the testing under conditions that would have an observable difference in wind drift.
The Field Test
I found the conditions I wanted on a private range in eastern Montana with a wind averaging 13 mph from the left and a distance of 275 yards. The testing was conducted on September 13th, 2022 with a shooting friend.
I had acquired some CCI Velocitor which has a 40 grain bullet. The testing Bryan Litz did of this cartridge measured a muzzle velocity of 1395 fps, a standard deviation of muzzle velocity (SD of MV) of 20.1, and a ballistics coefficient (BC) of .115. I had some Lapua Center X for which Litz tested a muzzle velocity of 1064 fps, a SD of MV of 7.2 fps, and a BC of .155.
The rifle in testing is a CPA Stevens 44½ with iron sights.
As I was shooting, I videotaped the bullet impact points at 32x magnification. Using video editing software and Photoshop I created an image showing the impact point of each shot. The impacts of the Lapua Center X bullets are in red and those of the CCI Velocitor are in blue. The vertical lines mark the horizontal center of each group, and the ram is the aiming point.
According to the Applied Ballistics Analytics solver, the Lapua has a time of flight of .905 seconds and the CCI has a time of flight of .814 seconds. It takes the Lapua longer to reach the target than the CCI, so it would seem the Lapua would have more wind drift. But as we can see, the CCI Velocitor — with the shorter time of flight — has more wind drift.
The data also shows how a variation in wind speed causes a wider horizontal spread of impacts. For the Lapua Center X, a 1 mph change in wind speed causes the impact to move 2.31 inches at 275 yards; the same change for the CCI Velocitor results in a 3.94 inch movement.
So Why Doesn’t Wind Drift Behave the Way Common Sense Says?
It turns out there is more involved in wind drift than just the time it takes the bullet to reach the target. The amount the bullet drifts is determined by what is called Lag Time.
Consider the hypothetical scenario where two bullets with the same muzzle velocity and ballistics coefficient are fired at the same time at the same target. Imagine one does not slow down as it travels downrange (like in a vacuum) and the other does slow down due to air resistance. The one slowing down will lag behind the one not slowing down. When the bullet that is not slowing down reaches the target, the other one will spend a period of time still arriving. That period is the Lag Time.
The Lag Time equals the actual Time of Flight (Tf) minus the “Time of Flight in a Vacuum” (Tv):
It is that Lag Time multiplied by the wind speed that determines the wind drift. Written as an equation:
- D = wind drift in inches
- W = portion of wind speed perpendicular to the bullet’s line of flight, in inches per second
- Tf = bullet’s actual time of flight in seconds
- Tv = bullet’s time of flight to the target in a vacuum, in seconds
This equation isn’t something someone came up with because they thought it would give a good approximation. It’s derived from the laws of physics.
Why Higher MV Means More Lag Time at .22LR Speeds
For the following to be easier to understand it is better to think of the bullet as stationary and the wind blowing into the bullet at the bullet’s velocity. The drag on the bullet is caused by the kinetic energy of the air moving past it. As the velocity of the air going past the bullet increases, so does its kinetic energy — but not in a directly proportional way. Doubling the air velocity does not double the energy; it quadruples it (energy ∝ velocity²).
At 10 fps the air’s available energy can be represented as 10 × 10 = 100. At 20 fps it’s 20 × 20 = 400. At 30 fps it jumps to 900.
There are a lot of forces acting on the bullet as its velocity moves from above to below the speed of sound. These forces don’t act only at the speed of sound but over a range from about 20% above to 20% below it — for a speed of sound of 1100 fps, that range is roughly 1320 fps down to 880 fps. This range is called the Transonic Zone.
For .22 rimfire and black powder era cartridges the bullet’s velocity usually starts out at the upper range of the Transonic Zone or a little above and, depending on distance, drops out of the Transonic Zone at longer ranges before reaching the target. Modern cartridge shooters with much higher muzzle velocities usually keep their bullets out of the transonic zone entirely. We don’t have that option — our bullets are in the Transonic Zone for most or all of the time of flight.
The Drag Coefficient (DC) graph is often misread as representing actual drag. It does not. To get the actual drag at a particular velocity you must multiply the air’s available energy at that velocity by the DC for that velocity. As the bullet’s velocity increases from low to higher values, the total drag at first does not increase much, until we approach the Transonic Zone where it climbs dramatically. Beyond the Transonic Zone the DC drops back somewhat, but the drag continues to increase because the air’s available energy keeps climbing.
Running the Numbers
The Lapua Center X starts at 1064 fps at the muzzle and is doing 805 fps at 275 yards. The CCI Velocitor starts at 1395 fps and drops to 907 fps at 275 yards. The Lapua loses 259 fps; the CCI loses 488 fps. Let’s plug these into the wind drift equation.
Lapua Center X
W = 13 mph = 228.8 inches/sec (mph × 17.6)
Tv = 825 ft ÷ 1064 fps = .7754 sec
Tf = .905 sec
Lag Time = .905 − .7754 = .1296 sec
D = 228.8 × .1296 = 29.63 inches
CCI Velocitor
W = 228.8 in/sec (same wind, same distance)
Tv = 825 ÷ 1395 = .5915 sec
Tf = .814 sec (less than the Lapua’s)
Lag Time = .814 − .5915 = .2225 sec
D = 228.8 × .2225 = 50.91 inches
It’s the larger Lag Time of the CCI Velocitor that results in the larger wind drift. Part of that is the CCI’s lower BC — if it shared the Lapua’s .155 BC, its drift would be 40.27 inches: significantly less, but still more than the Lapua’s 30.01 inches.
The CCI starts much higher up the drag coefficient curve, meaning it’s being slowed by a higher percentage of the air’s kinetic energy — and that energy is much larger at higher velocities. The overall drag on the CCI Velocitor is about twice that of the Lapua Center X as each leaves the muzzle, so the CCI loses velocity faster early in flight. Because its muzzle velocity is much higher, its Tv (vacuum time) is much smaller — and so its Lag Time (Tf − Tv) is larger. Larger Lag Time, larger wind drift.
The Sweet Spot
In conclusion: at lower muzzle velocities, an increase in MV results in an increase in Lag Time, and therefore an increase in wind drift. There’s an interesting consequence of this — the least wind drift sits around the 900 fps MV range. Go below that and wind drift increases. Go above 900 fps and wind drift increases until muzzle velocity gets up into the high teens (the exact crossover varies by cartridge). Above that point an increase in MV finally results in a decrease in wind drift, as we see with modern high-velocity cartridges. But MV has to climb into the upper 2000 fps before wind drift gets back down to what it was around 900 fps.
For the Lapua tested above under standard atmospheric conditions, at around 900 fps the wind drift in a 10 mph wind is about 22.79 inches at 275 yards. Of course, slower loads carry their own cost: more vertical drop, and SD of MV matters more than ever for vertical spread. But low SD-of-MV ammunition like Center X keeps that vertical spread small.
A number of years ago I was talking to a shooter running a 45-70 who wanted to reach 1000 yards. He had a Sharps in 45-120 on order so he could push the same bullet to about 1500 fps, thinking it would have less wind drift. Running the numbers on a 500 grain .458 bullet at standard atmosphere with a SD of MV of 10 fps and a BC of .400: at 1100 fps, drift is 66.15 inches and vertical spread from MV variation is 94.07 inches. At 1500 fps, drift climbs to 83.98 inches, but vertical spread drops to 49.39 inches. So while wind drift increases about 17.83 inches, the vertical spread decreases 41.68 inches. Trade-offs everywhere.
The best way to study all of this is with a ballistics solver. Set it up with the data for your load, then change one input at a time and watch how the output values move.
People sometimes assume the .17 HMR has less drop and less wind drift than the standard .22 Long Rifle. It does have less drop, but it has more wind drift than the Lapua and a little less than the CCI Velocitor.
There are a lot of things to consider when working up a load for a particular cartridge. Having a correct understanding of what a change in muzzle velocity does to wind drift at the low muzzle velocities of black powder era and .22 rimfire cartridges is important — but it’s only one of many things to take into account.
Article by Gary Riecke. Reproduced for the Texas Long Gong .22LR Knowledge Base.
Community rating
Comments on Wind Drift vs Muzzle Velocity